Skip to content
ExtraCreditLENDING MADE SIMPLE

The HELOC Payback Trap: Why a 7.9% Rate Can Still Cost You

A home equity line carries the lowest rate most business owners will ever see, 7.9% to 13% fixed, but the trap is the payback, not the rate: $100,000 at 8.5% over 10 years costs $48,783 in interest if you let it run, more dollars than a 12-month advance at a 1.30 factor costs. Use it when the business can earn more than the total payback and cover the payment in a slow month, and pay it down fast. Your house is the collateral.

By Josh Jones, in small business lending since 2010 · Updated

Key takeaways

  • Fixed rates on a business-purpose home equity line run from 7.9% to 13%. In our experience, many unsecured business loans run 20% to 55% APR.
  • $100,000 at 8.5% over 10 years is $1,240 a month and $48,783 in interest if you keep it to the end. Paid off in 2 years, the interest is $15,905.
  • APR compares like with like. A low rate stretched over 10 years can cost more dollars than a high rate over 12 months.
  • The house is the collateral. If the business fails, the lien stays. If you sell, the line is paid off at closing on top of the mortgage.
  • The test: the business has to earn more than the total payback and cover the monthly payment in a slow month.

Trapped liquidity

The housing equity boom has created a huge amount of trapped liquidity in this country. US mortgage holders had $11.7 trillion in equity they could borrow against in mid-2026, about $212,000 each.

A lot of it is staying put. Higher rates are the main tool for fighting inflation, and one effect is that many homeowners are not moving until housing affordability adjusts. The equity sits in the house.

For a business owner, a home equity line of credit is the way to put some of it to work. It can fund in days. A standard SBA 7(a) loan takes 3 to 6 months. Other money that can arrive within a day or two costs far more than this product.

That is the good news. This guide is about what it costs, and how to keep a low rate from turning into an expensive loan. Our home equity guide covers the basics.

The rate is real

Fixed rates on a business-purpose home equity line run from 7.9% to 13%, set by your credit, how much of the home’s value you borrow, and whether the line sits behind a mortgage. In our experience, many unsecured business loans run 20% to 55% APR.

How much you can get depends on your income, your ability to carry the payment, and the equity in the house. The Business HELOC page has the current rate table and requirements.

Nothing else in small business lending pairs a near-bank rate with funding in days. That is exactly why it gets misused.

The trap is the payback

The rate trap with a HELOC is not understanding your total payback: every payment you will make, added up. A seemingly attractive rate over 10 years can cost you a significant amount in interest.

Here is the same $100,000 line at 8.5% over 10 years, with a $1,240 monthly payment. The only thing that changes is when you pay it off.

Paid off after Interest you paid Balance you still owe
1 year $8,246 $93,367
2 years $15,905 $86,148
5 years $34,824 $60,432
10 years $48,783 $0

Add the origination fee on top, up to $4,990 on $100,000 for the lowest rate.

Now put that next to the expensive option. A $100,000 advance at a 1.30 factor over 12 months costs $30,000. That is about 54% APR. The line at 8.5%, kept for 10 years, costs $48,783 in interest. The low rate costs more dollars.

That does not make the advance the better deal. You had the line’s money for 10 years and the advance’s for one. It means the rate alone does not tell you what you will pay.

APR compares like with like

An APR is a proxy for cost. It is best used when you compare a like product with a like payback term against another. A 10-year line and a 12-month advance are not alike, so their APRs answer different questions.

The factor rate vs APR guide explains how the yearly number is built. The short version for this decision: compare dollars over the time you will actually use the money.

When APR is misunderstood, two things tend to happen.

  • Debt gets refinanced into the line and stays there. The owner pays off short-term financing with the line, the payment drops, and the line runs for years. The old debt is gone, but the clock now runs in years instead of months.
  • The business use earns less than the line costs. The money goes into something that never earns back $48,783, and it feels fine because the payment is lower than anything else on offer.

Both are sold on a lower monthly payment. A low payment is not a low cost.

If you are paying off a short-term balance, ask the lender you are leaving whether the payoff qualifies for a discount. Our early payoff guide shows why that can change the number by thousands.

A shorter clock costs less

The same $100,000 at the same 8.5%, set up over 5 years instead of 10, is $2,052 a month and $23,099 in interest over the term. The payment is higher. The total is less than half.

If the business can carry the higher payment, the shorter term keeps the debt from outliving the reason you borrowed. If it cannot, borrow less.

The house is the collateral

The other challenge is that your house secures this debt. If the business fails, the lien persists and does its job. A failed business does not cancel the line, and the payment still comes due.

It is also personal debt. It reports on your credit behind your first mortgage.

Selling the house

If a life change means selling, the HELOC balance has to be paid off at closing on top of whatever is owed on the mortgage. Both come out of the sale before you see a dollar.

That is fine in a rising market. It gets tricky if the house was appraised high in a hot market and you borrowed heavily against it. Then selling out of need can mean bringing cash to the closing table.

An illustration. The home appraised at $600,000 when the line opened, and you drew the full $100,000. Two years later the market is down 10% and the house sells for $540,000. We assume 6% for agent commissions and closing costs, $32,400. Yours will differ.

Borrowed 80% of the value Borrowed 90% of the value
Sale price $540,000 $540,000
Selling costs at 6% $32,400 $32,400
First mortgage balance at sale $375,000 $435,000
HELOC balance after 2 years $86,148 $86,148
What you walk away with $46,452 You bring $13,548 to closing

The same line, the same rate, the same house. The only difference is how much of the home’s value was borrowed. Know your number before you draw.

When it fits

Understand the intended purpose and the total payback before you sign. If the use fits, and the return the business can generate exceeds the payback cost while covering the monthly payment, then great.

  • A use with a return you can estimate: equipment, a build-out, buying a practice or a competitor, or replacing expensive short-term debt you will not refill.
  • A plan to pay it down, not just a payment you can afford.
  • A payment the business can cover in a slow month, from its own cash flow.
  • Equity you can afford to tie up, with room left if the market dips.

When something shorter is better

If the business needs a smaller injection of capital and can pay it back in months, not years, a shorter product can be the better fit even at a higher rate. The business can more easily account for the debt and keep liquidity high over the long term, without putting future choices about where you live at risk.

A line of credit is one option. You draw what you need and pay interest only on what you use.

And if the business is losing money, do not borrow against the house to cover it. That turns one problem into two.

Figures checked and published November 18, 2026.

Sources

Common questions

Is a HELOC cheaper than a business loan?

By rate, almost always. Fixed rates on a business-purpose line run from 7.9% to 13%. In dollars, it depends on how long you keep the money. $100,000 at 8.5% costs $8,246 in interest in the first year and $48,783 if you let it run 10 years. A 12-month advance at a 1.30 factor costs $30,000. Compare the total payback for the time you will actually use the money.

What is the total payback on a HELOC?

Every payment you will make, added up. On $100,000 at 8.5% over 10 years, that is $148,783: the $100,000 plus $48,783 in interest. Add the origination fee, up to 4.99% of the draw. Ask the lender for the total, not just the payment.

Should I use a HELOC to pay off expensive business debt?

It can save a lot, if you pay the line down fast and do not refill the old debt. Moving a short-term balance onto a 10-year line lowers the payment, but the clock gets longer, and a low payment you stretch out can cost more dollars than the debt you replaced. Ask the lender you are leaving about an early payoff discount first.

What happens to my HELOC if I sell my house?

It is paid off from the sale at closing, after the first mortgage. If the house sells for less than you expected and you borrowed heavily against it, the sale may not cover both loans and the selling costs, and you bring cash to closing. Check the math before you list.

What happens if the business fails?

You still owe the line, and the lien on your home stays until it is paid. The business failing does not cancel the debt. Borrow only what the business can repay from its own cash flow.

See what your business may qualify for

No obligation. About 60 seconds.

See My Options