Skip to content
ExtraCreditLENDING MADE SIMPLE

Equipment Lease vs Loan: Which One Costs Less

Start with how long the equipment will be useful to you. If it will earn for longer than the financing term, a loan wins: you own it, you pay less in total, and the resale value is yours. If the technology will move on before the payments end, a lease can win, because you hand the risk of owning an old machine back to the lessor and pay a higher total for the privilege. The lower lease payment is not a discount. It is the lessor keeping the machine's end-of-term value, plus a premium in the rate.

By Josh Jones, in small business lending since 2010 · Updated

Key takeaways

  • Match the financing to the useful life. A machine that works for 10 years or more should be bought on a loan. A machine the trade replaces every 4 to 6 years is the only case where a lease is worth pricing.
  • On a $75,000 mill at the same 7.5% rate over 60 months, the loan is $1,503 a month and $90,171 in total. A fair market value lease is $1,296 a month, $77,762 over the term, and the machine still belongs to the lessor. Buying it out at $15,000 brings the lease to $92,762.
  • The lease payment is almost exactly the payment on a 72-month loan ($1,297). The loan ends with you owning the equipment. The lease ends with a return, a buyout, or a new lease.
  • A $1 buyout lease is a loan with a different name. The IRS treats it as a purchase, you depreciate the equipment, and you should price it against an equipment loan, not against a fair market value lease.
  • An equipment loan pays for what is on the dealer's invoice. Delivery, installation, training, and the months before the machine earns are soft costs, and working capital financing covers them alongside the loan.

The question is the useful life, not the payment

A lease and a loan both put the machine on your floor this month. They part ways at the end of the term. On a loan, the last payment leaves you owning the equipment outright. On a lease, the last payment leaves you with a choice: give it back, buy it at a price set in the contract, or sign again.

So the first question is not “which payment is lower?” It is “how long will this machine earn for me?” The answer decides the rest:

  • Longer than the financing term. Buy it on a loan. Every month of use after the last payment is use you do not pay for, and the resale value is yours.
  • Shorter than the financing term. Price a lease. The lessor takes the machine back before it is worth little, and you move to the current model.
  • About the same. Run both numbers, the way the example below does, and lean toward the loan.

Two pages on this site show the two ends of that range. A dental chair and treatment unit is a 10-year-or-more asset, and the page says buy it. A dental mill has a 4 to 6 year working life before the software, materials, and speed move on, and the page calls the choice open.

What a lease is, and the two kinds

A lease is a rental with a long term. The lessor buys the equipment from the dealer and owns it. You pay to use it for the term, commonly 12 to 60 months, and the contract says what happens at the end. Two kinds cover most of the market.

A fair market value lease. The payment is the lowest you will see on a given machine, because the lessor expects to get the machine back and sell it, or sell it to you, at the end. At term end you return it, renew, or buy it at its then market value. This is the lease the technology trade uses. You never own the equipment unless you buy it out.

A $1 buyout lease. The payment is close to a loan payment, because the lessor is recovering the whole price over the term. At the end you buy the equipment for $1 and own it. In substance this is a loan. The IRS says so too: when an agreement lets you buy the property for a nominal price, or part of each payment builds equity you would receive, it is treated as a conditional sales contract, you are the purchaser, and you recover the cost through depreciation rather than deducting the payments as rent. If a dealer offers you a $1 buyout lease, compare it with an equipment loan, not with a fair market value lease, and look at the rate.

One machine, both ways

Take the $75,000 mill and scanner setup from our dental mill page, because it is the case where the choice is open. Finance all of it. Hold the rate equal on both products, at the 7.5% starting rate our primary lending partner publishes for equipment loans, so the comparison shows what the structure does and not what any lessor’s rate is. Lessors do not publish rates, and we will not guess at one, so the lease rate here is an assumption, and so is the 20% residual the lessor expects the mill to be worth in five years.

Over 60 months at 7.5% Monthly payment Paid over the term At the end
Equipment loan on $75,000 $1,503 $90,171 You own the mill
Fair market value lease, 20% residual, returned $1,296 $77,762 You hand it back
Fair market value lease, 20% residual, bought out $1,296 $92,762 You own the mill after paying $15,000 more

The lease saves $207 a month. Over five years that is $12,409 less paid out of the practice, and at the end you have no mill. Buy it at the $15,000 residual and you have paid $92,762 for a machine the loan would have handed you for $90,171, a difference of $2,591, with the rate held equal.

Look at the lease payment once more. $1,296 a month is almost exactly what the same mill costs on a 72-month loan, $1,297 a month. Both stretch the price over a longer horizon than 60 months; the lease does it by leaving $15,000 to the end, the loan by adding a year. One ends with the lessor owning the machine. The other ends with you owning it.

Now add a premium. Lessors earn a return on the equipment they own as well as on the money they lend, and the rate built into a lease is not the rate on a loan. If the lease is priced at 9.5% instead of 7.5%, two points higher, the payment is $1,379, the term costs $82,732, and the buyout brings it to $97,732, which is $7,561 more than the loan. The payment is still lower than the loan’s. The total is not. That is the pattern to look for on any lease quote: a lower payment, a higher total, and the equipment belonging to someone else until you pay for it again.

When the loan wins: long-life machines

A machine that outlasts the financing is the case for a loan, and most business equipment is in that group. Chairs and treatment units run 10 years or more. Bucket trucks, roll formers, coil lines, X-ray generators, and ultrasound consoles are 7 to 10 year assets or longer. On a 72-month loan, a 10-year machine gives you 48 months of paid-off use. A 15-year machine gives you 108 months, 9 years of work on equipment nobody is billing you for.

Resale value is the second half of the case. A dental chair that has served one practice still lists for five figures as a refurbished package. That value is what the lessor is pricing when it offers the low payment: it expects to own something worth selling at the end. On a loan, that value is yours from the first payment.

Two more things favor the loan on long-life equipment:

  • No prepayment penalty. Our primary lending partner publishes none on equipment loans. If the machine earns faster than planned, pay the 72-month loan on a 60-month schedule and keep the interest.
  • Up to 100% financed. Qualified buyers put nothing down, so the cash-preservation argument for leasing, keeping money in the business, applies to the loan as well.

When the lease wins: short-life technology

A lease earns its place when the machine will be out of date before a loan is paid off. Mills and scanners at 4 to 6 years are the dental example. Servers, imaging software, and some lab analyzers behave the same way. A 60-month loan on a 4-year asset ends with a year of payments on a machine the practice has already stopped using, or sold for less than the balance.

A fair market value lease with a 36 or 48-month term returns the machine while the lessor can still sell it, and you move to the current model. The risk that the machine is worth little by then sits with the lessor. The price of that protection is the premium in the rate and the resale value you give up, both shown in the table above.

A lease also fits a business that needs the lowest possible payment while new capacity fills, and accepts the higher total cost for it. Before you take that trade, price the 72-month loan: on the mill it carries almost the same payment and ends in ownership.

Two cautions on leases. Read the end-of-term section before you sign. Evergreen clauses are common in equipment leases: the lease renews on its own unless you give written notice in a set window, often 30 days or more before the term ends, and a missed window can mean another full term. The buyout on a fair market value lease is at the lessor’s valuation, not yours. And ask who pays for insurance and maintenance during the term, and what condition the machine must be in when it goes back.

Taxes, in plain words

The two are taxed differently, and the difference is often oversold. A loan buys the equipment, so you own it and deduct its cost through depreciation. Section 179 lets a business deduct some or all of the cost of qualifying equipment in the year it is placed in service rather than over several years. For tax year 2026 the limit is $2,560,000, and it phases out dollar for dollar once the equipment you place in service that year exceeds $4,090,000. Financed equipment qualifies the same as equipment bought for cash; what matters is that you own it and put it to work by December 31. Interest on the loan is a separate deduction. Separately, 100% first-year bonus depreciation is back for qualifying property acquired after January 19, 2025.

A true lease is different: you do not own the machine, so you cannot depreciate it or take Section 179 on it. You deduct the lease payments as rent. A $1 buyout lease is treated as a purchase, as above, so it follows the loan rules.

Two points keep this honest. First, the deduction is a timing difference: the whole cost is deducted eventually either way, and Section 179 moves it forward. Second, the deduction does not pay for the machine. A $75,000 deduction at a 25% combined tax rate is worth about $18,750 of tax saved, on a loan or a lease. Buy equipment that earns, then let your accountant pick the deduction. We do not give tax advice; your own position, your state, and your entity type all change the answer.

One point that used to favor leasing has mostly gone. Operating leases longer than 12 months now sit on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability, under the accounting standard private companies adopted for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2021. A lease no longer keeps debt off the statement a bank reads.

Working capital for what the loan does not cover

An equipment loan pays the dealer for what is on the dealer’s invoice: the machine, and the installation, software, and warranty when the dealer quotes them together. It does not pay for the rest. A contractor’s electrical or plumbing work, outside training, the inventory or staff the machine needs to earn, and the months before it earns are soft costs, and lenders will not roll most of them into the loan. The same is true of a lease.

Plan for them separately. Working capital financing covers those costs alongside the equipment loan: the equipment on a fixed monthly payment matched to its working life, the soft costs on a term loan or a line of credit sized to the gap. Our guide to a line of credit against a term loan shows which fits the soft costs you have. Apply for the larger need first; each lender counts your existing payments when it sizes the next offer.

How to decide in five questions

  1. How many years will this machine earn for me? Longer than the term, buy. Shorter, price a lease.
  2. What is the total I will pay? Payments times months, plus any buyout, plus fees. Compare totals, not payments.
  3. What happens at the end? On a lease, read the return, renewal, and buyout terms and the notice window. On a loan, confirm there is no prepayment penalty.
  4. What rate is built into this? A lease quote rarely shows one. Ask for it, or back it out from the payment, the price, and the residual.
  5. What is not on the invoice? Installation, rough-in, training, the slow months. Line those up on working capital before the machine arrives.

Our equipment financing page has the terms, and the documents guide lists what the lender will ask for, which starts with the dealer’s written quote.

How we calculated this

The loan is $75,000 at 7.5% a year, repaid in 60 equal monthly payments, with interest charged monthly on the remaining balance. The lease uses the same rate and term; its payment repays the price less the present value of a $15,000 residual over 60 months, and the buyout row adds the $15,000 at the end. The 9.5% lease and the 72-month loan use the same formulas. Dollar figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, so a total can differ from payment times months by a dollar or two. The 7.5% is our primary lending partner’s published starting rate for equipment loans; the lease rate, the two-point premium, and the 20% residual are assumptions chosen to show the structure, not quotes. Figures checked and published November 5, 2026.

Rates, residuals, and fees are set by each lender and lessor and vary by file. This is an illustration, not an offer.

Sources

Common questions

Is it cheaper to lease or finance equipment?

A loan is cheaper in total for equipment you will keep. A lease has the lower monthly payment, but at the end of the term you either return the equipment or buy it at its market value, so you pay more in total or own nothing. In our example, a $75,000 machine costs $90,171 on a 60-month loan at 7.5% and $92,762 on a 60-month lease at the same rate once you buy it out. The lease is cheaper only if you return the machine and did not want to keep it.

What is the difference between a fair market value lease and a $1 buyout lease?

A fair market value lease has a lower payment because the lessor keeps the equipment's end-of-term value. When the term ends you return the machine, renew, or buy it at its market price. A $1 buyout lease has a payment close to a loan payment and transfers ownership to you for $1 at the end. The IRS treats a $1 buyout lease as a purchase, so you depreciate the equipment rather than deducting the payments as rent.

Can I take the Section 179 deduction on financed equipment?

Generally yes. Section 179 applies to qualifying equipment you buy and place in service during the tax year, whether you pay cash or finance it. For 2026 the deduction limit is $2,560,000 and begins to phase out above $4,090,000 of equipment placed in service. On a true lease you do not own the equipment, so you deduct the lease payments as rent instead. Confirm either treatment with your tax adviser; we do not give tax advice.

When does leasing equipment make sense?

When the equipment will be out of date before a loan would be paid off. Dental mills and scanners, imaging software, servers, and other technology with a 4 to 6 year working life are the usual cases. A lease lets you return the machine at the end of the term and move to the current model, and the risk that it is worth little by then sits with the lessor. You pay for that protection in the total cost.

Does the lender pay for installation and training on an equipment loan?

Only when they are on the dealer's invoice. An equipment loan pays the dealer for the equipment and whatever the dealer quotes with it, such as installation and a warranty. A contractor's electrical work, staff training from a third party, and the months before the machine earns are not on the invoice, and lenders will not roll most of them in. Working capital financing covers those costs alongside the equipment loan.

Can I get a lease through ExtraCredit?

Sometimes. Our primary lending partner offers leasing only when the equipment vendor allows it. Every equipment loan through our marketplace is a purchase: up to 100% of the cost, terms up to 72 months, rates from 7.5%, and no prepayment penalty, so you can pay it off early if the machine earns faster than planned.

See what your business may qualify for

No obligation. About 60 seconds.

See My Options